My younger sister and I are 6 years apart. While we are close now, it wasn’t always this way. In fact, for most of our childhood, I was the mean, bossy older sister and my sister was the annoying little sister. With the way our schools were laid out grade-wise, we never even attended the same school and 6 years seemed ages and worlds apart.
Me and my sister, circa 1989 — look at how bossy I was even in this picture holding back her permed hair so you could see my face!
I once nannied for a family that had 4 children, with 2 years between each sibling. They were the cutest set of brothers and sisters ever and played so well with each other, especially with the sibling directly older or younger than them. I still keep in touch with them via FB, and it seems they are all great friends now in their teens and twenties. With that experience and the experience of watching my own friends that had siblings closer in age to them, I’ve always thought that a two or three year difference between siblings would be ideal. It would be close enough for the children to grow up as friends, but also far enough apart where they could also have their own friends and interests apart from one another. I appreciate the fact that with a 2-3 year age difference, there would be some overlap in schooling, particularly in high school and college, which would mean that the kids might be able to relate to one another and help each other out (and protect each other from high school meanies!). Again, this is what seems ideal and would all happen in a perfect world — I know plenty of siblings that are 2-3 years apart and didn’t get along through their adolescent years!
Well, you know what they say about the best-laid plans, right? Try as we might have to time things just so in order for Lil’ CB and a younger sibling to be between 2-3 years apart, those plans did indeed go astray. When we first submitted our application for a second adoption, we thought that our referral would come within a few months, the way the timing was with Lil’ CB’s process. But, delays and 14 long months later, we received a referral nearly a year later than we had originally anticipated. Of course, we are overjoyed at our recent news (and thank you so very much for your sweet, kind, and encouraging words and for celebrating with us!), and know that of course, things worked out the way they did because our Lil’ Cowgirl was meant to be our daughter! But, we are now looking at a 3 year and 9 month difference between our little ones, which also translates into a difference of 4 grade levels.
It’s definitely not a huge deal nor one that I am at all sad about, but it does make me think about what things might look like once Lil’ CG comes home in the next two years. By then, Lil’ CB will be a full-fledged school-aged kid, probably in first grade, and Lil’ CG will be a toddler. It’ll be interesting to juggle around a 6 year-old’s schedule with a still napping (I hope!) 2 year-old’s schedule and find activities that will be suitable for both. I can also imagine the transition from going from one independent (by then) 6 year-old to adding a very-much-not-independent 2 year-old will be a little challenging. Not to mention dealing with homework issues along side toddler tantrums! And I know there will be times when one of them will be bored out of their minds (similar to when my sister was dragged along to my very long violin recitals or me to her Brownies ceremonies, I’m sure)!
It also means our little ones will not be in school together apart from 3 years in elementary school, which means 8 straight years of our kids in high school and then college (I shudder to think about them being that old!!). Again, not a big deal, but funny how just 1 extra year seems to make quite a difference.
I do hope that even with them being in different schools and stages, our kiddos will be able to grow up as friends and really enjoy one another despite a larger age-gap. And yes, I realize I’m being a little silly pondering all this well before our Lil’ CG is home, but at least it keeps my mind busy from the wait!
What is the age gap between your little ones? What would be your ideal age gap?
guest
My kiddos are 13 months apart, 18 months apart, and 2 years 9 months apart. I have 3 boys and 1 girl. All of my boys are very close and love being with each other almost all of the time. My daughter is only 5 months old so we’ll see what she brings to the equation in the coming year. Seeing how close my children are I do wish I could’ve gotten pregnant with my daughter sooner sometimes.
blogger / coconut / 8306 posts
I’m the oldest of three. There is nearly 5 years between my brother and I, and 7.5 between my sister and I. We grew up close and still are, though the age difference between my sister and I is starting to show. 30 and 22 seem worlds apart! For some reason 20 and 12 didn’t
Our kids will be about 35 months apart. Ideally, we wanted our kids closer in age.
blogger / nectarine / 2600 posts
I think its hard to know whats best. I always wanted a 2-3 year gap but after having DS I really thought about waiting til he was 4 to give me some extra time but then worried about the school thing to. In the end we got a 3 year gap and since we wouldnt know life any other way I have to say it works. I think in the end as with life the bets laid plans dont always work the way you think but its ok too because we never know whats the other choice anyway and the new one becomes our reality.
persimmon / 1165 posts
As a twin mom, my sons have an age gap of 1 minute, so basically, nonexistent. We’re 99% sure we’re two and through, so a part of me is sad that I don’t get to experience things again with another child. I think the positive side of having kids spread out is you get to enjoy things more the second time around (I think). I’m already sad that I have no more first birthdays, first steps or other baby milestones to celebrate since they’ve already both achieved them. I do however get to enjoy double the fun with them, so it’s still great. Just different.
guest
My younger sister and I are 4 years apart. We went through love and hate phases but I do remember playing with her a TON despite the age difference. Now, we live in the same town, we went to the same college and see each other almost every day. I have a sister who is 2 years older and we are close as well- so I would say they have a wonderful opportunity to be close to each other. Congratulations by the way!!
hostess / wonderful honeydew / 32460 posts
My kids are almost 21 months apart!
I always wanted kids 2.5 years apart, but I’m happy with their age gap!
admin / watermelon / 14210 posts
Charlie and Olive are 22 months apart and it was my ideal because I wanted them to be 2 grades apart. Since they have end of the year birthdays, even a slightly bigger gap would have meant a 3 grade difference between them. I think it all works out in the end, but these early years are tough so I wanted them condensed.
apricot / 287 posts
Mine are 19 months apart but because one has a late birthday and the other a summer birthday they will be one grade apart in school. I only just realized this and since they are still young I am unsure if this will be a positive or negative once they start school!
wonderful kiwi / 23653 posts
I had the exact childhood as you, Mrs. Cowgirl! My sister and I are 7 years apart and for most of our early life, she was the annoying little copycat and I was the mean teenager that bossed her around and made fun of her! The turning point came when I went away to college and she started becoming a teen. Then we got a lot closer.
I would never trade anything in the world for the relationship we have now, although it was a rocky start! I think my experiences made me more indifferent about age gaps between siblings & not so gung ho about having them super close together.
kiwi / 511 posts
I grew up with two older sisters and one younger so we were 19X1, 19X3, 19X5, 19X0 and it was an interesting mix. I was probably closest to the oldest mostly because she was older and wasn’t home. The second oldest really loved the baby of the family and was her protector and I didn’t get along with the second oldest at all. Fast forward we are all close but I am probably closest to the second oldest now. And that was before we ended up with a lot in common such as adoption and food allergies.
I wanted that 2 year gap for my kids but going the adoption route I just had no idea what I would get. I also had a very surprise pregnancy during the adoption process (funny thing I originally typed adoption pregnancy, I am sure other adoptive Moms can appreciate the slip up) so my two are 23 months and 1 day apart both boys. When everything was unplanned and a surprise I think this is pretty darn amazing.
Now that the littlest is approaching his 2nd birthday I am seeing the two play more together and they clearly like each other. Right now I think the little likes the older a bit more because of hero worship, and the older wants to do more with the little that he can’t yet simply due to size differences. Plus the little isn’t one to be bossed around. I think we are in for some very interesting times ahead both boys are very headstrong.
blogger / pomegranate / 3201 posts
We really wanted our kids to be two years apart, but it didn’t work out that way for us either. Oh well, things happen how they are supposed to!
Oh and FWIW, my mom is one of 6 and is now closest to her sister who is 10 years younger than her.
grapefruit / 4671 posts
My sister and I are 22 months apart and even though we love each other dearly we fought like crazy growing up and we do not have a friendship type of relationship at all. My brother and I are 6 years apart and he is my buddy. I think the age gap doesn;t matter, it is more of a personality thing.
guest
Aw, my brother and I are 4 years apart (I’m older), and we get along wonderfully! We always have. I always thought that our age gap helped make us better friends. We weren’t so close that we bugged each other, but weren’t so far that we couldn’t relate at all. I think your little ones will get along just fine!
cantaloupe / 6131 posts
My brother and I are almost exactly 4 years apart. I think it worked out really well because I was old enough to be able to be a reliable role-model or pseudo-parent to him, but still be able to be his friend and sister. We played a ton when we were kids and we didn’t even go to the same schools very often because I got into GATE and was shuffled around the school district. I think spacing us also helped my parents because they knew what to expect in high school from one kid before transitioning to the next. Same for college. The age gap also helped me to step in and mediate when my brother was at an impasse with my parents. I could reach him and speak to him in ways my parents just could not. My brother and I always were and still are very close. While we don’t gab on the phone every day like girls, he depends on me as his big sister and confidant and I have a mom-like pride in what a great man he’s become.
guest
My sister and I are 2.5 years apart (3 years in school) and, although we played together some growing up, I think if you ask my mom it was about 70% fighting/arguing to 30% playing. The adolescent years were the worst. We were in highschool together for a year and lived together for a year in college when we overlapped but I wouldn’t say that it was a positive experience. Now that we’re older, we are great friends, but I think we would be great friends even if there was a wider age gap. My mom and her sister are 10 years apart. My mom barely remembers her sister growing up (my mom is the older) but now they are also great friends as adults. There’s pros and cons to all of it but I definitely think that it’s the relationship as adults that matters most and that depends very little on the age gap
blogger / wonderful cherry / 21628 posts
My sister is 7 years younger than me. We really close now but found each other very annoying when we were young.
guest
This is something that my husband and I are debating right now – our little one is 16 months old, and my husband really wants us to get pregnant rightthisverysecond…but I feel like I just had her! I have a little brother who is 3 years younger than me and it was great; and while I do think that is the perfect age gap, I can’t even wrap my head about getting pregnant again! Also, I hear that going from one kid to two kids is MUCH harder than going from none to one….is that true? Sigh!
blogger / wonderful cherry / 21616 posts
If all continues as planned, my kids will be 6-7 years apart and I am not excited about it either
I also agree that 2-3 years is ideal – I’m much closer to my brother who is three years younger than me than my brother who is seven years younger than me. My sister is five years older and we didn’t become friends until we were both married, and now our sons are the same age.
honeydew / 7091 posts
I want my kids close in age for the same reasons.
Although, my sister and I are ~4 years apart, and have always been very close and loving. We shared a room until I was in 8th grade, and I think that really helped us be so close. Even after we got our own rooms, we still wanted to sleep together every night
kiwi / 511 posts
@Jody I think going from one to two is in some ways harder but in other ways easier, but the things that really matters are (1) your ability to live while sleep deprived (2) the temperament of the second child (including how well they sleep and eat not just personality wise).
We went from one child to two children in the span of 6 months so everything was crazy. We were learning to parent a 1.5 year old (his age when we brought him home) and then six months later we were still learning how to parent him, but on top of that we had to learn how to parent a newborn. Super stressful for me. But now that the younger is as old as our oldest was when we brought him home, we are only learning to parent one age at a time.
Both boys are different but we have more stuff in our bag of tricks so we know what worked for the older and try that first, and if it doesn’t work we go to some of the other things we tried at the various developmental points. It is like we had a cheat sheet to follow.
blogger / pear / 1563 posts
I know what you mean! With adoption it’s kind of impossible to space your kids out like you want to. We would have wanted 2-2.5 years, but who knows?
blogger / nectarine / 2010 posts
My brother and I are 17m apart and it was way too close. I think 4 or 5 years is ideal. Little M is two and getting independent. I absolutely love it and have zero desire to go back to diapers and breastfeeding any time soon! But I think whatever space you end up with seems ideal to a lot of people because once you’re living it, you can’t imagine things any other way.
kiwi / 556 posts
I think a lot of circumstances can change things. Brother one and I are 23 months apart. It would be a perfect gap, except he has disabilities, so in reality was much younger. We get on extremely well, but our relationship is less brother-sister than others. I was his full time caregiver for a while, which also makes a difference.
Brother two and I are 6 years apart. As kids this was a large gap. As adults we are on the same plane.
Sister and I are 19 1/2 years apart. This creates an entirely different dynamic.
blogger / pomegranate / 3491 posts
I grew up with a sister three years younger and we are only now closer as adults. Never got along as kids/teens. I think personally matters as much if not more than age.
nectarine / 2152 posts
I’m 3.5 years older than my brother and we were close growing up and still are today! I think it’s good bc Lil CB will be much more patient and understanding than if he were a 2-year-old!
blogger / nectarine / 2687 posts
@Mrs. Chocolate: @Mrs. Stroller: yes, very true!
blogger / nectarine / 2687 posts
@Mrs. Pinata: i know, all sorts of twists and turns and unexpected stops in adoption journeys for sure! hoping you hear something soon!
blogger / nectarine / 2687 posts
@snowjewelz: yes, same here! and then when she went to college it got even better — and now that we’re both working adults, the age gap doesn’t seem as big of a deal. the only thing that’s a little hard is that our kids will be so far apart — my sister isn’t married yet, so i imagine the cousins will be several years apart!
blogger / nectarine / 2687 posts
@gingerbebe: that is incredibly sweet!!!
blogger / nectarine / 2687 posts
@Trailmix: very, very true (i hope)!
blogger / nectarine / 2687 posts
@plantains: @Mrs. Confetti: that’s a great point, and very true!
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
Noelle and Jaren are 26 months apart, and that’s exactly what we wanted. We were hoping for a 2-2.5 year age gap. I wanted them far enough apart that they weren’t going to be only one grade apart (my sister and I are only a grade apart and it was annoying because there wasn’t that clear distinction of older/younger), but close enough in age that they still have some overlap in certain things. They are getting along so well, and I love seeing my kids grow together!
So excited for you and your growing family – can’t wait to “meet” Callie!
GOLD / wonderful apricot / 22646 posts
My brother and I are only 20 months apart and super close. I would’ve loved to have our kid(s) be that close in age, but I was not ready until recently to consider ttc for #2. The way we are planning, it looks like DS and future LO could be 27-30+ months apart, which is still only 2.5 – 3+ years, so we will see how our ttc journey goes!
GOLD / apricot / 341 posts
We have 19 months between our first and second and will soon have 21 months between our second and third babies. I’m really happy about it as there are a ton of advantages to having kiddos close together. But I also feel the cons. Our first had to grow up pretty quickly when he became a big brother at just 19 months old. And our second definitely did not get the same quality of time with his parents as a baby since his older brother still needed so much attention.
We have friends who have just had their second 3 yrs and 8 months after their first, so just like your kiddos, @Mrs. Cowgirl: and it seems like a really good age gap (at least from the outside). Their eldest is able to understand the attention that the new baby requires and he has had such a long run of undivided attention from his parents. He is able to keep himself a little busy and plays quite well independently when needed. It just looks like a very peaceful age gap compared to some of the chaos that having kids really close together entails… Congratulations and good luck!
blogger / watermelon / 14218 posts
I originally wanted a 3-4 year age gap, and we ended up with 2 years 7 months and it’s been great for us!
You pushing your sister’s permed hair back… that photo has all kinds of awesome all over it!!!
bananas / 9118 posts
I think it just depends on the personalities involved. My brother and I were 4 years apart and fought like crazy as kids, as adults we get along much better now. He is the best uncle to my boys. My husband and his sister are 5 years apart and didn’t really become friends until they each got married (it helps that she and I are the same age and same life stage!) Our parents were all thrilled not to have two in college at the same time, it definitely helped spread the expense out a little.
My boys are 26 months, 1 week, and 1 minute apart (silly I know, but we did the math in the delivery room). We wanted 2 close together and will aim for a 3rd farther apart later on. Being close in age won’t guarantee that they be bffs though. There are pros and cons to all ages and by oldest is having some challenges adjusting to little brother right now. To me there is a reason for timing in everything, we can only change so much with our own plans
blogger / kiwi / 675 posts
my girls are 2y8m apart and sometimes we do wish they were even closer. Nonetheless, I think they are very close and hope they always will be. I like theyre spacing and they’ll actually only be two grades apart!
blogger / pomelo / 5361 posts
I always thought that a 2-3 year gap would be perfect; turns out 1-minute apart worked for us. :). We would probably like to have another, and we’ll definitely shoot for at least 3-ish years between them.
blogger / clementine / 998 posts
Maybe having a child that much older will be a bigger helper to you with the new baby