I’ve had lots of questions about the type of adoption we entered into with Isaiah. We entered into this as a completely closed adoption.
When we first met our birth mom, she didn’t want any contact. She didn’t want to see Isaiah in the hospital, and she didn’t want any contact with us. But I started going to her doctor’s visits with her, and we talked regularly. Neither of us expected it, but we formed a bond. I don’t know for certain, but I think it is safe to say that I’m one of the more consistent and most dependable relationships she has had in her life.
A few months in, she told me she would like to have pictures sent to her from time to time. I told her I didn’t have a problem with that, and I don’t.
A week before Isaiah was born, she told me she wanted to be able to send him gifts at Christmas and birthdays. We agreed that she could do this if she went through a third party, but that she wouldn’t contact us directly. We decided who the third party was, and everything was set.
Right before we left the hospital, our birth mom and birth father came into the room to say goodbye to Isaiah. Our birth father has not been part of the adoption at all. We met him late last year to see if he would feel comfortable allowing us to adopt his child. He and our birth mom are not and were not married during her pregnancy, so his parental rights were terminated last year. The last I had heard, he didn’t want to see Isaiah so we were surprised when he walked into our room to say goodbye. He hugged Mr. Polish and asked him to send pictures from time to time. He held Isaiah and told us that we looked like his family, and then told us that he was happy for us.
Our birth mom had a tearful goodbye, and to add to it, she didn’t only say goodbye to Isaiah, she was also saying goodbye to me. I’m not putting myself higher than I belong, but as a consistent part of her life, she was losing that too. As much as I was able, I tried to take care of her, and be a good support to her. I didn’t expect to feel sadness toward someone who also caused me such pain in the weeks leading up to Isaiah’s birth.
Just after Isaiah’s birth family said goodbye
I know that open adoptions are what is said to be best, but it isn’t something we’re entirely comfortable with. We didn’t put any limitations on the adoption that our birth mom didn’t agree with.
I’ve read about open adoptions on Hellobee and other community websites, and I don’t know how those families manage. Perhaps the distance they are from the original adoption date helps to calm the anxiousness, but the way I feel right now, I couldn’t do it. Emotions are still too high.
The Saturday after we left the hospital, the person we chose to use as a third party ran into our birth mom and she asked if she had heard from us. The third party told her that she hadn’t, and I felt like that was unfair.
Later that day our birth mom texted me, and even though we agreed not to directly contact, I felt like it was a good thing. She wanted to see if everything came back well on Isaiah’s newborn screen. I told her that he was as healthy as could be, and that I hoped she was doing well. She never texted back, so I can see that she is honoring her word.
There was no way I could not respond to her question about Isaiah’s well-being. I’ve felt intensively sensitive and compassionate toward her since we left the hospital, because when I try to think of how she might be feeling right now, it breaks my heart. I feel physically ill if I cannot see Isaiah, and thinking about what she’s going through absolutely hurts.
I don’t anticipate that our birth mom will contact us to meet any time soon. However, she has a ten year old son who was very upset about the adoption. I do anticipate that in the future he will contact us. Isaiah has other siblings who I also think will want to meet him. When that day comes we will handle it, but right now I don’t see it being a problem.
If you have, or know someone who has an open adoption, how does it work?
Open Adoptions part 3 of 5
1. The history of open adoption in the US by Mrs. Train2. Openness in adoption: striking the right balance by Mrs. Jacks
3. Open vs. Closed Adoption by Mrs. Polish
4. The Gift of Open Adoption: Part 1 by Mrs. Pinata
5. The Gift of Open Adoption: Part Two by Mrs. Pinata
GOLD / nectarine / 2884 posts
I find your sensitivity very inspiring! Since I’m not an adoptive momma I guess I shouldn’t really say anything….but I guess I feel like this is an example of how we sometimes don’t get to choose the relationships we have in life, they kinda choose us? This is obviously the most complicated example of this sort of thing. It is uncharted waters for most people and it is very brave of you to confront it!
hostess / wonderful persimmon / 25556 posts
I think you’re pretty strong to have been in contact with Isaiah’s birth mom through her pregnancy. I think if I were to adopt, it would have to be completely closed, with no contact whatsoever. I just don’t think I could handle the stress and emotional turmoil of it all.
hostess / wonderful persimmon / 25556 posts
Ps…does that sleeper have a whale on it?
GOLD / nectarine / 2884 posts
@mediagirl: my thoughts exactly! Because if so, we also have the same sleeper! Love it!
blogger / nectarine / 2010 posts
@Mrs. Sketchbook: @mediagirl: it does! It’s my favorite outfit!
Thank you both for your kind comments. I often told people close to me that this is the only situation that would cause me to have relationships like this. I am definitely wiser to the world around us now.
guest
Leah over at Single Infertile Female just adopted a baby, and she mentioned in a post that she set up a password-protected website that she could update with photos etc. for the birth mother. I’m not sure of logistics, but maybe that would be a good option for you to provide updates when it is convenient for you, and for the birth parents to receive updates when it is convenient for them? That could potentially eliminate some of the stress of having a third party involved. Not sure that you can/want to change your arrangement now, but it’s a thought.
blogger / pomegranate / 3300 posts
@Mrs. Polish: so I could write you a whole book. I am going to try to be brief. The short answer is it gets easier with time. I don’t know if you read much of our story but we ended up with a contested adoption. Before we adopted, we agreed to pictures and possibly a visit near Christmas and his birthday (born in November) we agreed to that. When we started to get into the court dates and drama with that she started asking for once a month. I hated it but our hands were tied because we wanted “to keep her on our side” according to our lawyer. Se would come and visit and tell me how he remembers her and tell me to cut his nails and I would just sit and nod and smile. When she left I would literally scream into a pillow or go break some ice cubes on the cement. (Ummm.. Not my finest momments but there you go). I was physically ill every time I thought about it. When we finalized we ended with three times a year for two years then four. For the birth father gets three a year. Each one is 2 hours but can be increased as he ages, at our discretion.
All of our lawyers told us eventually they would just stop and we wouldn’t have to deal with it. That has not been the case. The first year I still was getting physically ill each month we waited to hear from them but that has passed. Now it is just a part of what we do. I think that as my son grew older a bit and he was able to talk and call me mom I was less intimidated by the relationship with biological family.
I try very hard to open my heart to them but it seems like every time I do I get knocked back down by some thing they do. Last summer we found out the birth father was talking to his lawyer asking for more visits. When we found out we were floored. He had never mentioned it to us, why go straight to a lawyer which will costs us a fortune. So it has been a difficult road and ours is a very unusual case. Most open adoptions are not contracted through family court.
I think mrs. Jacks has the more common type of open adoption. She would have a more positive experience.
pomelo / 5321 posts
You are such a strong mama! I have no idea what I would choose if I were in your shoes. I can’t imagine making such hard decisions. I hope things become easier and less stressful as time goes on.
grapefruit / 4862 posts
Girl, you inspire me every day. I am so honored to know you both on here and sort of in real life, haha. I cannot wait to know Isaiah more as he grows and see the strong young man he becomes!
As for open adoption, I wish I knew who my birthparents were, but if I had to choose, I think having a closed adopted was better for me emotionally. Your situation would be the best, because if there were medical issues, or when Isaiah is an adult and if he wants to have a relationship and you want to look into it, you have a name. It’s almost impossible that I will ever find out my birthmother’s name and find her, ever, due to the laws of our adoption, which is devastating. It is just nice to know that that option is there for even 20, 30 years down the line if there is a need. I think it’s the best of both worlds for all of you!
blogger / nectarine / 2687 posts
man, i can’t imagine the emotions you must be going through as you think about this relationship and how to make it work for the best. for us, because of the nature of international adoption, it’s automatically a closed adoption. i’m not sure how much of a relationship we’d be comfortable with, but i’d love CB to at least know his birthmother’s name and what she looked like…i actually hope he’ll do a birthparent search when he is older and allowed to (at 13 according to the current laws in Korea), because i think it would be a great way for him to understand his story, but i will leave that completely up to him!
blogger / pineapple / 12381 posts
Our first year was completely through a third party. The only number they had for us was a google voice number. We wrote every stipulation into the contract so that things wouldn’t get muddy. We were to write and send pictures once a month for the first 6 months and then twice a year until age 18. Any other contact was at our discretion. They did not have our last names, address or phone numbers. We did set up an anonymous email account that they could use.
After the first year, it was clear that they are incredibly reliable an consistent so we amended the rules so that we have phone numbers (primarily for texting) and get together once a year. It seems ridiculous to spell it all out in such gory detail, but these boundaries have made it really smooth and prevent the regular pitfalls of open adoption (crossed boundaries and the necessity to close things).
Also we made sure birth father signed the paperwork (even if rights were terminated.)
nectarine / 2600 posts
I just read all of your posts from beginning to end, just wanted to say how happy I am for you.
blogger / nectarine / 2010 posts
@Mrs. Train: I read quite a bit of your story when I first came here. I can’t imagine what you went through, it tears me apart to think about. And the fact that the birth father went to his lawyer. I’m praying for you and your family. What a tough situation.
Thanks for taking the time to reply with your story!
blogger / nectarine / 2010 posts
@KJfromNJ: I’m so surprised to hear you say that you think closed is best for you. I would have thought for sure you would have said open. Thanks for your sweet comment. One of these days you’ll meet us in person. I swear.
blogger / nectarine / 2010 posts
@Mrs. Cowgirl: wow, 13 seems so young to me! Are you not allowed to search?
blogger / nectarine / 2010 posts
@Mrs. Jacks: I think it’s awesome you were able to establish boundaries like this. Knowing our birth mom I can’t see anything like this working very well, but if she wants more regular contact we will give it a shot.
blogger / nectarine / 2010 posts
@BB@TheSwissWifeStyle: thank you! I’m glad you read them!
guest
We’re in the process of open adoption and I must tell you, every single adoption is different, just like every child is different.
How I envision our open adoption is like this: the bm & bf become a part of our lives, we invite them for visits, we go visit them (either together or separately). We communicate regularly via text/Facebook/blogging/email/etc. The get to see their child grow up and our child gets to know where he/she came from. Our child would get to know their extended family as well.
That would be how I would want our open adoption to go in a perfect world. I’m very hopeful it could happen!
Your son is gorgeous! I hope you continue to communicate with your son’s birthmother and that maybe someday it will open up more!
Thanks for sharing your story!
blogger / persimmon / 1398 posts
Thank you for sharing this!!! I was wondering, but afraid to ask.
like @mrs. Cowgirl… We also have a closed adoption being that we adopted from Korea. At times, it’s really rough… But I think my lil’ guy will search for her when he is older. We do have identifying info… which means we could probably try to track her down… But we think S should be the one who makes that decision… Not us.
bananas / 9973 posts
I don’t have anything to input on adoptions. Just wanted to say this beautifully written, sensitive and honest post brought a tear to my eye. I can only imagine both sides.
On a somewhat related note, watched Juno again during a late night the first week home with baby and I was bawling at the end. It’s gotta be immensely difficult for both sides