In preparation for “the terrible two’s,” I’ve been reading The Happiest Toddler on the Block.
One chapter I found interesting was the temperament chapter. The author carves out nine main traits of temperament, and lumps these nine into three major categories. What I also found intriguing was the percentages associated with each type.
1) Easy kids (40%) – these kids are flexible, active, not too intense, and open to new situations. They wake up on the right side of the bed in the morning, cheerful and ready for a new day.
2) Cautious kids (15%) – are also called “slow to warm up.” Hesitant, sensitive, even fearful, they don’t like changes and surprises. They tend to be peaceful but are easily frustrated. These are the kids who insist on watching other kids go down the slide for twenty minutes before they get up the confidence to carefully try it themselves.
3) Spirited kids (10%) – are also called “challenging.” These are the “more” kids: more active, more intense, more sensitive, more passionate, more inflexible, more moody, more impatient, impulsive, and strong-willed.
Now I don’t know how the author derived at these percentages other than his own experiences as a pediatrician, but it is largely on par with my own observations. I haven’t met a lot of cautious or spirited kids, but I have met a lot of what I see as “easier” babies. Though I personally don’t like the label – Easy – because parenthood is anything but!
Noelle definitely falls into the 2nd category, and when I see other kids I often think, every baby seems easier and more independent than Noelle. I’ve frequently wondered if I did something wrong, or why she isn’t as sociable as other kids. As a parent, it’s hard not to take credit for the things your kid does – both the good and the bad. They really do feel like an extension of us. But I can tell you now that Noelle has been this way since birth. She was cautious very early on, and when people say babies don’t hit stranger anxiety til they’re 9-months, I’d have to kindly disagree because Noelle’s been in her “stranger danger” phase since she was about 3-months! She is a mama’s girl through and through and often clings to me as if her life depended on it.
The upside is I rarely have to worry about her getting into trouble. She’s super careful when she does anything. Babyproofing has never been much of an issue for us. She’s never played with cords or tried to stick her finger in outlets. As soon as I tell her, “it’s dangerous,” she’ll shy away from that previous object of interest. I can leave her on the couch/bed unattended and trust her to climb down safely. She is so delicate and tender in her movements, and rarely ever aggressive in her actions.
Here’s a recent picture of Noelle at her friend’s 1st birthday party. These other kids are happily playing with ice, and although Noelle LOVES playing with ice (when she’s in safe, familiar surroundings)… in this scene she is a mere observer. She did not once try to reach in and touch that ice.
Other quotes I was able to really relate to when it comes to my cautious toddler:
“By four months, when many babies hand out smiles like free samples, cautious infants frown with worry at the sight of a stranger and retreat to their moms for rescue.”
“They usually offer generous waves of bye-byes — only after the guests have walked out the front door.”
“Your child’s cautious temperament was not caused by you being overly protective or ‘giving in.’ Your child has been this way from birth.”
I really think her temperament will be a huge relief in her teenage years. My husband was a straight and narrow type of guy who always stayed out of trouble, so the apple doesn’t fall very far from the tree. Even now, he is cautious and deliberate with everything he does. These are the things I appreciate about him because I can be impulsive and really quick to act. It’s funny how I see so much of me, but also so much of him in our little girl. It’s easy to understand and love your kid when they feel like a mirror image of you. So narcissistic huh?? Lol. I’m always noticing things she does that’s “just like me!” or “just like Mr. HH!”
I can’t wait to read the rest of this book. Just this chapter alone was so interesting. Even though these were traits I already recognized in my daughter, it helps to see it on paper.
Is your LO easy, cautious, or spirited?
Hellobee Series: Mrs. High Heels part 1 of 14
1. The Cautious Temperament by Mrs. High Heels2. The Case for a Doula by Mrs. High Heels
3. Confessions of an (Ex) Cloth-Diapering Mom by Mrs. High Heels
4. How the High Heelers Budget by Mrs. High Heels
5. College Funding with 529 Plans by Mrs. High Heels
6. 20 Questions to ask when Interviewing a Preschool by Mrs. High Heels
7. Korean-Chinese Postpartum Rituals by Mrs. High Heels
8. The Vaccination Debate by Mrs. High Heels
9. Mrs. High Heels' Sleep Training Story by Mrs. Bee
10. Our Peanut Butter Scare by Mrs. High Heels
11. Our Birth Plan for an Unmedicated Hospital Birth by Mrs. High Heels
12. You Need a Budget!! by Mrs. High Heels
13. Our Meal Planning Process by Mrs. High Heels
14. Pumping at Work by Mrs. High Heels
GOLD / pear / 1845 posts
Mine is fairy cautious as well. She’s much braver at two then she was at 1.5 though!
wonderful clementine / 24134 posts
I loved the other book, “Happiest Baby on the Block” and based on this review I think I may pick up this one as well.
I have met a few of each “type” of child. And I do think its just the way they are from birth!
cantaloupe / 6730 posts
What are the other 35% of children?
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
@grace – the other 35% are considered a little bit of each with no clear category (according to the book)
clementine / 958 posts
At nine months, I already know my daughter falls into the cautious category, too. I’ve actually had complete strangers berate me in grocery store checkout lines because my daughter wouldn’t smile at them. She’s perfectly happy to smile, wave, clap, etc for people she knows, but she is very weary of strangers. I have a copy of this book sitting on my shelf – now I’m looking forward to reading it!
pomelo / 5178 posts
There’s another common description of children’s temperments called “flexible, fearful, or fiesty.” If you google that phrase, a lot of information comes up with strategies/techniques/ pointers on how to manage each temperment type.
I’ve been lucky that both of my kids are in the “flexible” category; although I believe DD is a little more toward the “fearful” side of the spectrum and DS is a little more toward the “fiesty” side of the spectrum.
honeydew / 7504 posts
Really interesting! I would have to say that Hubs and I probably would both be considered Easy, with a tendency towards Cautious. I am so anxious to see how our LO will turn out!
blogger / wonderful cherry / 21628 posts
This is interesting. I was a cautious child and I’m still cautious.
guest
In many, many years of working with tiny kiddos I’d have to agree with his percentages too. I would classify my 8 month old as somewhere between cautious and spirited. Cautious when in a new situation or around new people, spirited the rest of the time. Your comment about stranger anxiety starting at three months rang true to me. My little guy has always stared strangers down without even a hint of a smile!
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
@owlmom – while i’ve never had anyone outright berate me for my serious, cautious girl… i’ve seen the judgment behind people’s eyes when she won’t give them even the hint of a smile. i’ve learned to not “apologize” for who she is, but i do catch myself trying to “justify” why she is the way she is. i have a lot of non-parent friends, so i don’t think they get that some things are just out of our control and not every baby is naturally happy, bubbly, and friendly towards others!
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
@honeybee – ooo i’ll have to google that! is there a book that you got those descriptions from? how did you find out about them?
the only other book i’ve read that really categorizes temperaments comes from “the baby whisperer”, but i couldn’t identify with her descriptions as much.
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
@thehistoryofus – i got this book at a used bookstore for 50 cents, but i get a lot of parenting books from paperbackswap.com. you should check it out! you send other ppl books for just the cost of shipping (so i usually post light books)… and every time they receive a book you get 1 credit on your account. with every credit, you can get a book in return!
hostess / eggplant / 11068 posts
I think LO is “more”! Oh no! LOL!
pomelo / 5178 posts
@Mrs. High Heels: Actually, our daycare provider told me about it; it’s a whole program designed to teach caretakers how to manage different temperment types. There’s a whole scale with 7 different categories of behavior that help you figure out the child’s temperment, and then are different strategies for dealing with each type. Here’s some websites with more info:
http://www.wacasa.org/conference/handouts/B-11.pdf
http://www.parecovery.org/documents/Focus_ECMH_Temperaments_010810.pdf
http://www.earlychildhoodnews.com/earlychildhood/article_view.aspx?ArticleID=554
blogger / pomelo / 5400 posts
I just started this book! I think Baby Y is somewhere between “easy” and “cautious.”
blogger / wonderful cherry / 21616 posts
My son is definitely “easy”. He is so go-with-the-flow, smile for anyone, happy-go-lucky babe.
I have nannyed for MANY spirited children however- boy are they little spitfires lol.
I haven’t met very many cautious kids though…
admin / watermelon / 14210 posts
i think both charlie and olive are easy. charlie did have stranger anxiety from 5-6 months until around 1 year, but he grew out of it. olive lets anyone hold her. even with easy babies, it’s still hard so i cant imagine what it’s like to have a spirited child!
apricot / 275 posts
I was also a very cautious child and am a pretty cautious adult as well! Interesting
GOLD / wonderful coffee bean / 18478 posts
@Honeybee: our daycare also uses the same descriptions. They made me feel better that I didn’t “make” my DD this way … I would describe her as mainly “cautious” but I can see her in the “more” category, too.
@Mrs. High Heels: I also think it is wonderful to have a cautious child because they don’t place themselves in dangerous situations and we haven’t had to worry too much about child proofing either. I also think that they are smart to have such a strong sense of self preservation.
hostess / wonderful honeydew / 32460 posts
My LO’s about 90% easy and 10% spirited!
olive / 70 posts
My first daughter is definitely cautious. My second is easy. Raising both of them side by side, I can’t help but see the differences. Audrey will not smile at strangers and is very hesitant about trying new things. Katie smiles at everybody. It’s so interesting to see how different kids are in terms of temperament.
blogger / pineapple / 12381 posts
Lala is an interesting mix. She’s cautious with people, but fearless with things. M. is just easy!
GOLD / olive / 58 posts
Thank you for the very informative links, @honeybee!
My daughter must be in the 5 % of the Spirited kids category! She is super difficult and intense. She fits ALL the described characteristics and MORE.
I have yet to meet another child as difficult as her.
Ugh, I feel like I need a vacation every day!
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
@mamapink – those are the people who change the world
blogger / persimmon / 1220 posts
I’d say A is Easy! (Although I wouldn’t have said that in the early months…)
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
@mrs. checkers – A seems Easy!
so does almost every baby i/we know (at least compared to N)… N is definitely NOT easy. hoping the next one will be!!