Inspired by a couple of recent board threads on what baby gear you really used, I thought I’d share what we found to be worth it. I’m a huge proponent of buying used baby gear, especially the big stuff like swings, exersaucers, and jumperoos that you need early on but quickly outgrow. Then if something doesn’t work out, you can always resell it at the same price so you don’t have to worry too much about wasting money. That’s what I did with a lot of our baby gear (like the Puj tub which didn’t work out for us).
Of course everyone is different and everyone has different needs, but this is what worked and didn’t work for us!
Bumbo – Yes but only if purchased used. I bought a used bumbo for $10, lent it to a friend when Charlie outgrew it, and now I have it back for Olive. So for the price, it was definitely worth it! Charlie loved sitting in his Bumbo and the newfound independence it afforded him. He was able to sit up for months before he could actually do it on his own, which came in handy when it came to playing with certain toys like his music table. The Bumbo can also work as a high chair in the early months. And some of our cutest Charlie pics are of him in the Bumbo! However the Bumbo is not great for chubby-legged babies, and I’ve heard that the Prince Lionheart Bebepod is much better.
Exersaucer – Yes. I felt like I constantly had to entertain Charlie whenever I was with him, which could get quite exhausting. The exersaucer proved to be a godsend because he could play in it for at least 20 minutes at a time. Many moms debate whether to get an exersaucer or a jumperoo because they take up so much space. If I had to choose based on what Charlie liked best, I’d go with the exersaucer.
Jumperoo – Could have lived without it. We had the popular Rainforest Jumperoo, and that thing is a monstrosity — something to consider if space is a constraint. While Charlie did like his jumperoo, he didn’t love it as much as his exersaucer. For the space it took up in our apartment, I didn’t feel it was worth how much time he spent in it. Some babies absolutely love jumperoos though, so it really depends on the baby. We didn’t have a doorway jumperoo, but that’s another option for the space restricted.
Bouncer – Yes. We used our bouncer every day of Charlie’s life until he outgrew it around the 5 month mark. We didn’t use the vibrating function so much as a place for him to sit every day and play with his toys. It also provided a safe place for him to hang out when we had to go to the bathroom. And now Olive uses the bouncer everyday!
Swing – Could have lived without it. A lot of parents tell you that they couldn’t have survived without a swing because most babies will sleep soundly in a swing, and you gotta do what you gotta go to survive those early months. Some moms on the other hand will tell you that their babies hated swings and to see if you can try one out before buying it. We were pretty diligent about putting Charlie to sleep in his crib so we didn’t use the swing that much except as a toy (Charlie loved the rotating lights mobile on it).
Wipes Warmer – Could have lived without it. This is the number one thing that people will tell you is a waste of money. But my mom would have a heart attack if she saw me wiping a newborn’s butt with cold wipes! This definitely falls into the unnecessary column, but we still use ours and have always liked having warm wipes.
Bottle Warmer – Yes. This is probably the number two thing that people will tell you is unnecessary. If we were mixing formula with room temperature water, I wouldn’t bother with a warmer. But since Charlie was mostly bottle fed pumped breast milk that was refrigerated, a warmer was very convenient. Running a bottle under warm water took much longer, and you never knew when it was warm enough. We also figured out what settings to use on our bottle warmer so that it maintained the perfect temperature until Charlie got out of the bath to a nice bottle waiting for him. So for us, I think it was a necessity, especially since we still use it for Olive.
Infant Car Seat – Yes. We opted to buy an infant car seat vs. a convertible car seat and it really worked out for us because we used it with a stroller frame. That enabled us to postpone making a decision on our stroller until we better knew what our needs would be. It was also very convenient to be able to pop the car seat out of the frame without disturbing a sleeping Charlie.
Baby Scale – No. Although it was fun to track Charlie and Olive’s weight gain, this was a completely unnecessary purchase. Olive was a preemie but gained weight so quickly that there was no need for us to moniter her weight.
Bassinet – No. I bought a bassinet so I could carry Charlie from room to room when he was sleeping, but I never used it and ended up selling it.
Pack n Play – Yes but not as a bassinet, playard or for travel. It was an excellent and affordable crib to keep at Grandma’s house though.
Baby Food Maker – No. I bought a Beaba because we didn’t have a food processor, but it makes such small quantities that I would steam everything in a separate pot. That defeats the purpose of the Beaba since it’s supposed to save you time by allowing you to steam and puree in one machine. If we had a food processor, I definitely wouldn’t have purchased a Beaba because it’s something you use for such a short period of time. But at least baby food makers do have a high resale value.
Baby Monitor – Yes. Many people will tell you that a baby monitor is an unnecessary purchase, and I believe that it is for some people. For worriers like me, and people who sleep train, I don’t know how you survive without a video monitor! A video monitor enables me to see if Charlie is just settling down so I don’t go into his room too quickly and unnecessarily wake him up. Video monitors also have high resale values.
Diaper Pail – No. Newborn baby poop doesn’t really smell. But once babies start eating real solids, most diaper pails can’t contain the smell. Plus diaper pails hold so many diapers and the older your child gets, the less diapers you change. That means it takes a long time to fill your diaper pail which means it will be extra stinky.
Changing Table – No. Most people don’t use changing tables nowadays and opt for the changing pad on top of the dresser action. We did the same.
Bottle Sterilizer – No. I sterilized bottles for the first month of Charlie and Olive’s life, but I think sterilizing before first use or just running them through the dishwasher is more than fine. I hadn’t been planning on sterilizing Olive’s bottles, but the only reason I did was because she was a preemie.
Newborn Mittens – No. Onesies with special sleeves that cover hands are more effective. Or if you prefer, you can use socks!
Baby Shoes – No. I didn’t buy Charlie any shoes until he started walking because shoes are expensive and it’s easier for babies to learn how to walk on bare feet. Up until Charlie started walking, he wore slipper socks or soft soled shoes from Target when we were outdoors.
Newborn Sized Clothes – Yes, but not too many. It’s really amazing how fast your baby grows the first 6 months. You tend to stay home a lot in those early months as well, so you really need very few clothes in newborn, 3 months and 6 month sizes… especially dressy clothes. Footed sleepers are the easiest things for your baby to live in.
Crib Bumpers – No with a caveat. The American Academy of Pediatrics just came out against crib bumpers. We didn’t have the fluffy traditional bumpers, but we did have breathable bumpers once Charlie started rolling over. He’d get his arms and legs caught in the slats and the breathable bumpers prevented that without us having to worry about SIDS.
Moby – No. I bought a Moby because it was one of the most highly rated baby wraps. Turns out that I’m not really a wrap person, and it was so complicated to use that I didn’t have the patience for it. Don’t get me wrong – some moms swear by the Moby/baby carriers. But I would try them out in person first (or buy used), to make sure that they work for you and your lifestyle.
Bath Thermometer – No. This was a completely useless purchase since ours broke after a couple of months. But Mr. Bee loves to take boiling hot baths, so we did find it useful to make sure the water wasn’t too hot. Still a pretty unnecessary purchase.
Receiving Blankets – No. My mom bought us a bunch so we did use them, but they certainly weren’t necessary. Big swaddling blankets like the Aden & Anais muslin blankets were much more useful.
What baby gear did you find to be worth it? What baby gear was a waste?
persimmon / 1255 posts
I agree with most of the things you listed above. For me, I can think of two things that I found surprisingly useful: shopping cart cover and the Bebepod.
I bought a pre-owned shopping cart cover for $5 thinking that I probably wouldn’t use it that much but it’s actually one of the things I use the most. It’s main purpose is to protect your LO from germs but I actually like it because it’s a more secure harness than the regular shopping cart straps. I also use it on restaurant high chairs and to better secure my LO in infant swings.
I never intended to buy a bumbo seat cause I read that chubby babies get stuck in them and my LO was one CHUBBY baby but then my neighbor let me borrow her Prince Lionheart Bebepod (which has wider leg openings) and I found it so useful, I bought it from her. My LO is now 1 yr old and I still use it everyday. I place it on my vanity counter and buckle my LO in; She sits there and brushes her teeth (ok, she chews on her toothbrush) while I put on make-up. The base is wider and heavier than the bumbo so it’s less likely to tip over.
pomegranate / 3503 posts
Thanks for this. Been deciding between an Exersaucer and the jumperoo for our second child who’s now 4 months. We had borrowed the jumperoo from a friend for our son at the time and he loved it. But it has such a large foot print, so I’ve been leaning towards an Exersaucer this time around.
pear / 1639 posts
The infant car seat was a must, and he loved his swing. I didn’t use the diaper pail, a wipe warmer, bottle warmer, changing table, mittens, shoes, sleep sacks, swaddle blankets, or bath thermometer (although the real thermometer was used all the time!). I used my front pack baby carrier a couple times, but it was a pain with all the buckles, and my wrap was horrible! It looked so uncomfortable, and I felt like DS was going to fall out the whole time!
apricot / 498 posts
Our infant car seat is a bust. Love our Bebepod, Ergo, Uppababy Vista and the bouncy chair though. And the grandparents are buying him an exersaucer for Christmas. Never had a wipe warmer, bottle warmer, diaper pail or bath temp reader.
admin / watermelon / 14210 posts
@Red: yes i’ve heard the bebepod is much better for chunky legged babies. for some reason the bumbo is more popular. maybe it’s the cute name!
clementine / 889 posts
DS much prefers his jumperoo to the exersaucer. His grandparents bought the jumperoo for their house on weekends and he loves it. But we did get a doorway jumper, so he can get a change of scenery from one to the other.
We never warmed bottles for DS, we would just set the bottle on the counter for bit and he’d drink it right down. If he didn’t take it cold, we might have bought a warmer, but I’m glad we didn’t buy one before finding out.
The wipes warmer was something we skipped and never missed. We also skipped the diaper pail and just use a garbage pail with a swing lid (we cloth diaper). I didn’t get a baby food maker either, which I’m really glad about, because in the end I just don’t have time to make his baby food so we use Earth’s Best purees.
DS never fit into a single newborn outfit or diaper. We also skipped a crib bumper. I didn’t think they were safe, and he only got a foot stuck once. He cried, I fixed it, and that was that. Now his feet are too big to get stuck really, so it was money well saved.
kiwi / 500 posts
DD never really enjoyed the jumperoo, she just hates anything that confines her. The longest I got was 10-15 minutes out of her in that thing. I did buy the bumbo but then returned it for the more expensive Mamas & Papas for the fact that it does have wider leg openings and it already comes with the front tray and it has a longer shelf life since you can remove the plastic seat and use it into toddlerhood. I do get pretty good use out of that.
I was gifted a bouncer, never really used it except to hold DD in a a handful of times while I grabbed something. She didn’t like sitting in it, didn’t like the vibrations either. I was gifted the wipes warmer too. I really liked it. Maybe she was born in the colder months so I thought it was soo cruel to wipe her with a chilly wet wipe. I had the munchkin one and if you use it right, it doesn’t dry the wipes out at all. Is it a necessity, no? But for $20 It doesn’t really dent the bank either.
We did end up getting a bottle warmer after I stopped breastfeeding. She had gotten accustomed to warmer bottles thanks to my in-laws, even after repeatedly telling them room temperature would have been fine. It took too long to warm in a warm water bath. I used my sisters and I thought it was worth it. I don’t use it quite as much anymore as I just find it more convenient to heat water in an electric kettle and then cooling it down and transferring it to a good thermos.
One of the stupidest things I spent money on, was the mamaroo. I was one of those idiots that fell for it. DD just never really cared for it and I got maybe 4 uses out of that stupid $200 space waster.
blogger / pomelo / 5400 posts
So funny how different babies are. The Bumbo is definitely on our “didn’t need” list, but the swing and Jumperoo were and are still lifesavers!
pomegranate / 3716 posts
What a great list!
And Charlie… I just want to eat him up! That pic is the cutest!
pomegranate / 3053 posts
When my son was learning to walk we got him the Radio Flyer classic walker wagon. I felt it helped him learn how to walk a lot faster. He started walking at 11 months on the dot. Other things that I still love from infant to now (31 months) is a shopping cart cover and a high chair cover. I’ve read about what was discovered on both and just got totally grossed out. I have two separate ones only b/c they were each very reasonably priced (both $10 each). I’m such a germ-aware person and hate wasting wipes wiping everything down so these are great to have if you’re like me. Umbrella stroller is another one. We have three strollers and the one that gets used the most is the umbrella stroller b/c it’s lightweight and doesn’t take up much space in the trunk.
pear / 1852 posts
I wonder what I’ll find useful, and not so useful.
You’re not the first to suggest a Bumbo chair to me, I think we may have to check that out next year. thanks!
pea / 16 posts
Oh my goodness! I’m pregnant with my first so I have nothing useful to say about baby gear, but I’m so excited about your site! I adored Weddingbee when I was engaged in 2007-8 and I’m so happy to have found you here. Congrats on your beautiful family, Mrs. Bee!
wonderful pear / 26210 posts
Re: the bumbo, if you get the tray it is a bit difficult to put on with the baby in it, I’ve heard the BeBePod is easier to attach the tray to.
I really needed the bath thermometer, I have no idea how hot water really is because I tend to like really hot water for showers and washing dishes.
apricot / 260 posts
We lived by the swing in the beginning because there were times Wombat wouldn’t be happy in my arms, nursing, or anything else. She was happy in the swing. And I’m also a mom who swears by the Moby. I cook dinner wearing it, make crafty stuff, and walk around. It’s awesome, but I would’ve never taken the time to figure it out if it hadn’t been a gift.
persimmon / 1329 posts
I can’t believe how much Charlie’s grown compared to this pic. Times flies. So cute! I like how his smile is the same.
cherry / 114 posts
mrs. bee, can i ask which bottle warmer you have? i’ve looked at a couple, but none of them got great reviews. thanks!
admin / watermelon / 14210 posts
@dnmommy: sure thing! this is the one we have:
http://www.amazon.com/Philips-AVENT-iQ-Bottle-Warmer/dp/B001C3MHEQ/ref=sr_1_4?ie=UTF8&qid=1323208341&sr=8-4
it has mixed reviews, but we’ve warmed hundreds of bottles with it the past 2 years and have never had a problem.
cherry / 114 posts
@Mrs. Bee: thank you!
kiwi / 718 posts
I’ve wondered about if we need a bottle warmer, but I’m holding off as well, in the hopes that baby will take bottles that aren’t warmed. We’ve gotten a lot of hand-me-down stuff & are actively trying to avoid anything plastic {or majority plastic, as there are some things out there that you just can’t find with no plastic}, so that has thankfully whittled down the list of what we are & are not bringing into the house quite a bit as well. I’m sure I will refer back to this once baby is here, though!
kiwi / 718 posts
also, that picture of mr. charlie? would totally make my uterus cramp up in baby envy if it weren’t already housing one. so freaking cute
blogger / wonderful cherry / 21616 posts
what video monitor do you have?
I can’t seem to find one that has consistently good reviews.