A few days ago, I was talking to my husband, and was surprised to discover that he thought adding a second child to the mix was “exponentially – not just double – the work” (his exact words). I was shocked to hear this because my experience was so different! Whenever people ask, I usually say that adding a second child was not that drastic a change because I was already doing everything I needed to do with one child anyway, and I also had a lot more confidence as a second time mom. I guess he didn’t feel the same way!
When people ask, I always say the first 6 months were the hardest because our newborn obviously needed a lot of attention, but so did our first since our kids are only 2 years apart. I struggled to keep Noelle entertained while stuck to my glider nursing Jaren. She just did not have the attention span and focus that she gained once she hit 3. Looking back now, Noelle was still so young when Jaren came around. On top of that, we were re-acquainting ourselves with the second go-round of sleep deprivation. That deserves a post all its own.
Even though those first 6 months were “the hardest,” it still did not seem that bad to me – definitely not anything like the first time. I was so much more relaxed and self-assured. Everything came back to me as if it were second nature. The things that kept me up at night with my first were a non-issue with my second. What worried me the first time, I knew it would all pass. So I let it all go. I took it day-by-day until the days turned into months. The months went by in a blur, and before I knew it, a year had passed.
The reason I didn’t feel like adding a child was double (much less exponential) the work was because everything I was doing for my first, I had to do for my second anyway. Once Jaren started solids and was able to sit up, it meant I could feed and bathe them together. He needed less focused attention from us since his sister was always around to entertain him too. As for errands and activities, we just dragged him along because we needed to go with his sister anyway. He learned to sleep in the carseat and stroller because we couldn’t be tied to the house all the time when his big sister needed tending to too.
And even though my husband experienced these same things, I realize now why he thinks it was exponentially harder. With the addition of our second child, we had to divide and conquer. It was not just “one or the other.” Noelle was always a mama’s girl, so when we only had her, it was natural for me to take on the bulk of the “work.” I nursed her for a year, I prepared most of her food, I bathed her, and put her to sleep each night.
Once Jaren came along, guess who ended up doing the majority of the toddler duties? Yup. The one and only Mr. Heels. He handled the pickups and drop-offs, bathed her, fed her, put her to bed… many of the things I used to do. With the constant nursing and pumping and night feedings, it made more sense for him to take those on. I’m grateful I have such an involved husband and father who took on these duties without complaint – to the point that I had no idea he felt it was exponentially more work to add a second child to our family until 2 years after the fact!
The funny thing is, I feel like our marriage is stronger than ever now with two. I had wondered if adding a second would cause some strain on our marriage, but the opposite occurred. There were times when I felt resentful when we only had our daughter because I was doing the bulk of it. Even though he helped a lot… a lot still fell on my shoulders. I wanted to let him be a daddy, but the truth of the matter was, it was easier said than done. Noelle was an extreme mama’s girl. When she threw tantrums because she couldn’t have me when I was obviously right there, I didn’t have the heart to not be there for her. There was definitely a gate-keeping dynamic going on.
Now, it truly feels like we are a team, doing this parenting thing side-by-side, and getting better at it as we go. Because I couldn’t be as present and available once Jaren came along, he took over all of it, and him and Noelle have developed such a strong bond. She is solidly in the Daddy camp now, and I don’t mind it one bit. I love seeing their relationship blossom. So thank you, Mr. Heels, for taking on exponentially more, so that I have been able to say that it was just a little more, and not a lot more work with two.
Did you and your husband have different perspectives on adding an additional child to the family?
Transitioning to Two Kids part 6 of 9
1. Going from one to two by Mrs. Superhero2. The Difference with Two: On Parenting by Mrs. High Heels
3. The Difference with Two: On Lifestyle by Mrs. High Heels
4. Finding Time with the Second Child by Mrs. Chocolate
5. The first year with two kids by Mrs. Palette
6. What the Transition from 1 to 2 Children was like for My Husband by Mrs. High Heels
7. Tips for Transitioning to Two by Mrs. Deer
8. Prepping #1 for #2 by Mrs. Tricycle
9. The Transition to Two Under Two by Mrs. Rabbit
guest
Can you please to the sleep post? We’re getting ready for number 2, and little guy will be 21 months when baby is born (should mention he still doesn’t consistently sleep through the night!) so I’m terrified of dealing with an almost 2 year old and a newborn waking up during the night, then being a zombie since I can rest when the baby rests because I have my son to deal with who wants to play. I’m really nervous about this transition to 2…..
wonderful pomelo / 30692 posts
Thank you for this!! Our #2 is coming in December and ours will be right around 2 years apart too! I’m kind of worried about how my husband will handle it because he will definitely be taking on the bulk of Xander duties while I tend the newborn. He does a LOT now, but obviously he still has a lot of downtime when I’m the one watching Xander. That won’t be the case once #2 is here. I wonder if he’ll also find it exponentially harder…
pomegranate / 3565 posts
Nope, DH has taken the addition of our 2nd in stride. But honestly, he transitioned into parenthood easily! DS1 is a total daddy’s boy so he wants to be around DH all the time. I still do bath and bed time 90% of the time, but it’s my time with DS1 and I don’t really mind. My husband is just way more laid back than I am in general. Not much gets to him!
blogger / pomegranate / 3201 posts
This is so interesting! We recently visited our friends who have a one month old and a 3 year old and the mom said it hasn’t been that bad and the dad said it has been sooooo hard! I wanted to push more about why, but the conversation changed directions. I’m sure the same is true for them because their older daughter was definitely a mommy cling-on. She nursed until 2.5 and still sleeps in their bed. I bet the dad now has a lot more work to do than he did before!
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
@Jen: I’ll try to work on one! I think the newborn and toddler sleep ties into my husband thinking the transition was more work for him because I was already getting up with the newborn just like I had the first time around, so it was just something I had done before… but now it was up to him to tend to the toddler! Hopefully, your husband will be really involved and take that on while you focus on the newborn so you’re not the one juggling two kids with various wake ups.
@Adira: Sometimes I felt out of the two (dealing with a 2 year old vs a newborn), it was the newborn that was easier! My husband handled the bulk of the discipline and tantrums too. The “terrible two’s” really was just one big blurrrr to me.
@Mamasig: My DH is a very laid-back and easygoing guy too – he never complains either, I guess that’s why I had no idea he felt it was that much harder until now! He picked everything up like it was no big deal, but he does worry more than I do about cleanliness, and worries more about safety… with one kid it’s a lot easier to make sure they’re clean and safe, with two it’s a little harder (esp if you’re not a natural multi-tasker too like my DH!)
@mrs. tictactoe: Thanks for sharing that story! Interesting that this is the dynamic in other homes as well!
persimmon / 1472 posts
I was nodding my head the entire time reading your post! So much rings true in terms of the change in responsibilities in our household once #2 came along. With just DD1 I, too, took care of most of her needs since she is very attached to me. Now we have to divide our responsibilities and DH takes care of most of DD1’s needs while I tend to DD2. He stepped right up into the role and I need to give him more credit after reading your DH’s account of the changes!
wonderful pomelo / 30692 posts
@Mrs. High Heels: Ugh, I don’t even want to THINK of the Terrible Twos and how they are right around the corner and are going to be upon us when this baby shows up!!! I do not envy my husband having to handle the bulk of that! Luckily he’s pretty good at discipline in general, so hopefully it’ll all be okay…..
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
@Adira: Does it make you feel a little better if I tell you they are better than the 3’s? Haha! You have to use a lot more brainpower with the 3’s because they get really really REALLY good at negotiating. With the 2’s, timeouts, giving choices, and using tactics from How to Talk so Your Kid Will Listen were really effective for us. There will be meltdowns, but I feel like we’re already in the middle of that right now with where X and J are at… so it’ll just be more of the same! But then again, X is an angel so maybe you haven’t had to deal with that yet!
wonderful pomelo / 30692 posts
@Mrs. High Heels: hahaha, oh no, we’ve been dealing with tantrums and meltdowns! And Xander loves to test boundaries and refuses to take me seriously!! When Hubs tells him “No,” he stops doing whatever he’s doing, but when I tell him “No,” he just smiles at me and keeps doing it!!! Gahhh!!
And actually, it IS good to know the 3s are worse because at least by then, I’ll be back to being more involved and so Hubs won’t have to deal with that all on his own!!
cherry / 187 posts
This is so interesting! It makes sense why he thinks having 2 is harder. I totally need to ask my husband how he feels about this as I assumed he would feel the same as me that the second was definitely easier and not 2x or more work!
apricot / 457 posts
It actually really helped me to read this. I’m currently expecting and my LO will be 3 when #2 arrives and I was really worried because I kept hearing “exponential work” but this post made me realize I only heard this term from dads.
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
@tipperella: It’ll be interesting what he says – I’d love if you could report back.
@lisa1783: Same! Most mom’s I’ve talked to have said that 1-2 was easier than 0-1, and definitely not “exponential” or even “double” the work. More work, yes, but not as scary or hard as it seems.
papaya / 10473 posts
Thank you for this! Loved it!
apricot / 307 posts
I could’ve posted the exact same thing! It’s so funny because when people ask me about the transition from 1 to 2, I say it’s not terrible, but for DH it’s been a real shocker. He went from being only a part-time parent to almost 100% responsible for our toddler. There’s no down-time for him and it’s been a difficult transition. He’s been great, though, and he’s definitely stepped up. I think, too, it’s given him an appreciation or at least insight into how much I have to do.
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
@Boheme: I’m really really REALLY excited for you!!
@sooz: That’s so funny – I never really thought about a husband’s perspective on it all until I talked to my own. I completely agree with everything you said, esp your last sentence.
pomegranate / 3779 posts
No LO#2 yet, but I totally identify with everything you said about having only 1 and the work distribution being uneven. I have often wondered if having 2 makes it a bit easier to let go of some of the control and have things even out a bit.
pomegranate / 3565 posts
@Mrs. High Heels: I also just thought of something a male friend told me. He has 4 kids and thought all the even transitions were harder. That was because that’s when his work load increased!
cherry / 106 posts
My husband said the exact same thing. I could’ve written this post. So much so that he’s actually telling people not to have a 2nd child, jokingly but not. Haha…
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
@Mamasig: That’s enlightening! I have a coworker who told me to “stick to even numbers”, so as much as we are open to having 3 (just an inkling), we are definitely NOT open to 4. So I think we’ll just stick to 2.
@lollipop: Hahaha oh no that’s too funny!
blogger / coconut / 8306 posts
The opposite is true for us! We had such a great dynamic as a family of three; he was ways in charge of bath and bedtime (and that hadn’t changed), while I took care of dishes/laundry/general clean up while he tackled bedtime routine. Now I’m usually nursing the baby, so I have to fit in household chores in somewhere else.
I also have the added task (stress?!) of getting both kids ready and out the door in the mornings for preschool, which can be difficult!
The major difference this time is I am breastfeeding. I bottle fed our oldest, so we were able to tag-team feedings. This time, it’s all on me!
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
@Mrs. Jump Rope: You should definitely write a post with the alternative perspective! Hope things get more balanced again soon for you guys – it’s still pretty early on right now!
blogger / pomegranate / 3044 posts
how interesting! I think D’s whole situation makes us unable to do this sort of introspection… it’s definitely been exponentially harder for both of us!
pear / 1852 posts
In our house, Helen is definitely a mamas girl too, I’m always the one to feed and bathe her, and although she clearly loves her daddy, when she’s not feeling well, it’s me she turns too.
apricot / 370 posts
How interesting so many of you feel similarly, as it has been opposite for me…I feel like it is much harder and husband thinks it’s not that bad. We both have taken turns with dd1 taking care of her, waking up in the middle of the night for whatever it is and it is no different now with dd2. I felt like at least with one, we both got to take turns having breaks, but with 2, we’re both busy, now it’s amatter of who wants the harder kid at the moment lol. He’s pretty laid back though and I stress over every little detail, so there lies a big difference as well in our perspectives.
bananas / 9973 posts
This is a wonderful post, as always! I hear this “exponentially harder” thing tossed around quite a bit. Often times to further scare or intimidate my husband I feel like. And I KNOW it is true why: the mama does the bulk of the work for #1 and the dad has no choice but to pitch in more and shoulder more work with #2. My DH knows this as well, and I’m positive it’s the reason he is not excited to try for another. The strain part, I am really glad you wrote about. It worries me. Even my MIL told me it will put a strain on the marriage and maybe not worth it (because of other ppl in the family’s issues). I’m glad you think it strengthened your relationship. I sure hope that will be our case someday.
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
@Mrs. Tiger: I would love to read a day in the life, and many other posts, from you on how you juggle your two!
@Mrs. D: It is definitely a love/not love thing with the mama’s girl thing because it is so sweet that they find so much comfort in us, but so exhausting at the same time when they want nobody else but us. We transitioned all of DD’s duties to DH when I was still pregnant with #2 to get her more used to DH, and in the beginning, she still really wanted me… but she adjusted and DH and DD have the best relationship now. I’m so glad we worked on that while I was still pregnant, so that by the time the new baby came, it was no longer a big deal for DD that mommy wasn’t as available.
@kakimochi: How old and how many years apart are your kids? I hope you guys get some better sleep soon!
@shopaholic: HUGS lady! When I see how you are with K, I am amazed at how much energy you have to keep up with her day in and day out (not to mention how well-dressed she always is on top of all that and how put together you always look). Your DH is a lucky guy!! Hopefully, if/when #2 comes the divide will be more even and your marriage will be stronger for it.
nectarine / 2631 posts
Love this! And I am sending the link to DH so he can mentally prepare himself!
I think our kids will be *almost* the same age gap of yours!
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
@cheert16: LOL I love how you’re warning him already! What, you don’t think he’ll want to be surprised?
bananas / 9973 posts
@Mrs. High Heels: Thanks friend!
blogger / persimmon / 1398 posts
This is such a great post!!! One of my friends emailed me on one of my “bad” days that she found two “more than double the work.” That’s how I feel too! I’m not sure if it’s because I finally found my groove with one, or because they are so different, or because Pint-Sized is going through a ton… Regardless… it’s nice to know that there is someone else who felt a little blind-sided.